Darci Lynne and Terry Fator are two America’s Got Talent greats. They both won their respective seasons (Season 12 for Lynne; Season 2 for Fator) and for similar spellbinding talents: singing ventriloquism. They’ve each gone on to lead massively successful careers, selling out venues nationwide — and bringing their legendary puppet friends along the way.

So what happened, then, when these two icons — and their most iconic puppets — joined together for a musical duet? Magic. Pure magic.

Darci Lynne and Terry Fator’s duet of ‪”The Prayer” by Celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli‬ is an AGT symphony

This is precisely what went down around three years ago, when Lynne and her puppet, Petunia, hopped on a video call with Fator and his puppet, Winston, to sing “The Prayer” by Celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli‬. Lynne and Fator couldn’t have sounded better together — and, of course, the performance was even more jaw-dropping given the fact their mouths were shut the entire time. Fator matching Bocelli‬’s Broadway-operatic style for his vocal portion was particularly impressive. Seriously, how do these two do it?

Terry Fator and Darci Lynne arrives at the Red Carpet For “America’s Got Talent” Season 17 Finale at Sheraton Pasadena Hotel on September 14, 2022 in Pasadena, California. Photo: Steve Granitz/WireImage

“Petunia, you sing like an angel,” Winston “told” Petunia at the end of the performance, to which she “replied,” “And Winston, you sing like a turtle.” (Winston is, in fact, a turtle, hence the cheeky joke.) We love puppets who have a sense of humor!

Watch the performance for yourself, below: